USS Dragon - Guide to Godmodding

« Guide to Godmodding »

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.
Nov 20, 2009, 7:15pm

Help Build our new website!:

Donate Today!

USS Dragon :: Support and Feedback Area :: Dragon Feedback :: Guide to Godmodding

Author

Topic: Guide to Godmodding (Read 1,524 times)

Ben Babcock
Former Crew
Executive Officer
[image]

member is offline

[M:0]

Joined: May 2004
Gender: Male

Posts: 265
Karma: 1

Guide to Godmodding
« Thread Started on Feb 23, 2005, 5:58pm »

All right . . . I didn't want to do this, but this is something that's been getting on my nerves for quite some time. I realize that with a slow-moving forum RPG like this, you don't want to wait seven pages to get a response from someone, but I might as well post this to show some alternatives.

Godmodding or 'power-playing' as it is sometimes known, occurs when a player does something that forces another player to react in a certain way. It can be divided into several categories, but for now I'll look at the basic types.

Type 1: Miracle-worker

This is the least-commonly occurring one I've seen on these boards, which is good. There is a difference between being one of the best Starfleet officers in the quadrant and being an omnipotent being. The fun is sort of taken out of an RPG when you get a character who does something like this:

Quote:

Captain: Bob, repair the warp drive!
Bob: Done, sir.

Or even worse:

Quote:

Captain: Drat, we'll never catch that Borg cube now!
Bob: Wait sir, I've just modified the warp drive into super-cool hyper-transwarp engines, and increased our phaser efficiency by 200%!

The first type is bad because it leads to mediocre roleplaying. What fun is it when you ask someone to do something, and all they say is, "Done?" Instead, they could do this:

Quote:

Captain: Bob, repair the warp drive!
Bob: *checks the plasma injectors* I'm on it sir.
Bob: *corrects the antimatter flow valves*
Bob: *takes a coffee break*
Captain: Helloooo?
Bob: Almost done! *reboots Windows XP* Done, sir!

You don't necessarily need to even do this in more than one posts. Quality is better than quantity, but you can be a little more verbose.

The second example I showed you is worse, where a player suddenly works a miracle that will save the ship. Writers call this a 'deus ex machina' or 'God from the machine'.

A third example that falls under this category is when your character is fighting another character. It is true that some species are superior, but you can't always assume that. I haven't seen any of this on the Dragon, though.

Type 2: Control of Characters

This is the type of godmodding I see the most on the Dragon. The number 1 rule is that the control of a player's character remains in that person's hands (unless they say otherwise).

For example:

Quote:

John watched as Bob got up from the helm console and entered the turbolift, whose doors closed behind the helmsman.

This would force Bob to go into the turbolift. Yet what if Bob's player wanted Bob to go talk to the engineer on the upper level, or perhaps talk further to John?

By making another person's character do something in your post without their permission, you in effect take control away from them. If you specify their location or their actions as being different from their last post, then you're limiting their options.

Of course, if a player says that you're allowed to do that, then it is okay. Unfortunately the other players can't know this unless you tell them, so I urge other players to assume that the person posting has gotten permission. It'd be nice for the person posting to let us know though.

I know this may seem somewhat difficult to avoid, once again you can't wait seven pages to get a response from someone. But I've seen it happening often enough to get annoyed, and when I get annoyed I get verbose.

Type 3: Goodbye Storyline

The Dragon is definitely one of the most cooperative RPGs I've ever seen, in that every character contributes to the story. Although Captain Mayweather is in charge of the ultimate plot of a mission, I like the level of participation from the players.

Major plot changes remain in the hands of Mayweather for the simple reason that as the creator of the RPG, he's entitled to guide it along a path as he sees fit.

When another player does something that effects a major plot change (eg; when it will potentially affect the mission itself or most of the other characters) then they open up the RPG to the chaos of conflicting plot changes. If you have a plot suggestion, talk to Captain Mayweather.

When such a plot change happens, it is best for the other players to go about as if it was sanctioned, because as far as they know it could be. It is not their fault that the poster did not obtain permission, so they should not be expected to know. If someone posts a major plot change, assume it has been approved unless someone says otherwise. On that note, don't be the one to post a plot change without talking to the captain first.

If anyone is still reading at this point (congratulations) then I hope that this helped. Godmodding detracts from any RPG. Feel free to post any more questions or comments. I'm not directing this post toward anyone in particular, because everyone on this ship is a good RPer as far as I'm concerned, and everyone (including myself) has godmodded on occasion, it happens.

Link to Post - Back to Top IP:

Logged

cougar
Guest

Re: Guide to Godmodding
« Reply #1 on Mar 18, 2005, 3:14am »

well finally someone pointed this out. Good job tach!

Link to Post - Back to Top IP:

Logged

supernova
Guest

Re: Guide to Godmodding
« Reply #2 on Aug 23, 2005, 1:26pm »

I always wondered what godmodding meant....

Link to Post - Back to Top IP:

Logged

Jon Mayweather
Dragon Admin

Commanding Officer
[image]

Captain[M:0]
member is offline

[avatar]

"Captain Jon Mayweather- Explorer, Protector, Starfleet's gambit"

Joined: May 2004
Gender: Male

Posts: 844
Location: Canada, eh
Karma: 18

Re: Guide to Godmodding
« Reply #3 on Aug 23, 2005, 2:20pm »

yeah.. unti lhe poste dthis i wa s a major goddmodder..

Link to Post - Back to Top IP:

Logged

Items: Type2 Assult Rifle , Personal Phaser

supernova
Guest

Re: Guide to Godmodding
« Reply #4 on Aug 24, 2005, 10:10am »

Borgattack (Pikmin) was a godmodder....

Link to Post - Back to Top IP:

Logged

Ivan Stasnovich
Marines
First Lieutenant
[image]

Marine Fighter Pilot / Sniper[M:-150]
member is offline

[avatar]

Freedom, No matter the cost

Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 84
Karma: 3

Re: Guide to Godmodding
« Reply #5 on Aug 26, 2005, 9:10pm »

I know, he always tried to save the day when I was trying to set-up a climactic moment...I had to resort to deleting his posts in order to continue the story w/o "helm experience increases by 200!!!"
PS- for anyone who is thinking WTF?, I was captain of another RPG ship that is winding down now...time to move on

Link to Post - Back to Top IP: